Snow showers 26°5 Day Forecast
News Search

Advanced search
go
Home
Shop Now!
Classifieds
Jobs
Auto
Real Estate
Shopping
Place An Ad
News
Regional NewsPolice/CourtsBusinessBlog CentralObituariesWeatherAP - The WireTop Read StoriesMost Talked About
Sports
Life
Opinion
Classifieds
Las Noticias
Photo Galleries
People & Events
About Us
Other Publications
Entertainment
Doorways
Subscriptions
Fun and Games
Consumer Guide
Personal Finance
Lifestyles
USA Weekend
Special Section
Entertainment
Movies
TV
Crosswords
Horoscope
Fun & Games
Site Tools
Yellow Pages
Photo Galleries
Services
Subscribe
Photo Reprints
About Us
Daily Freeman Jobs
Home : News : News : Top Stories
Top Stories
Suspended teacher faces 49 charges in child porn case
By Molly Maeve Eagan, Freeman staff
01/03/2002
email this storyEmail to a friendpost a commentPost a Commentprinter friendlyPrinter-friendly

KINGSTON - A suspended Kingston High School teacher was indicted Wednesday on 49 criminal counts after an Ulster County grand jury saw sexual images from his computer, some involving children, and heard testimony from a Kingston High School student, according to county District Attorney Donald A. Williams.

Todd O'Brien, 25, of 115 Arnold Drive, town of Ulster, was indicted on three counts each of promoting an obscene sexual performance by a child and possessing an obscene sexual performance by a child, 35 counts of promoting a sexual performance by a child and one count of possessing a sexual performance by a child, all felonies; and five counts of obscenity and one count each of endangering the welfare of a child and sexual abuse, all misdemeanors.

He faces up to seven years in state prison for the most serious charge, promoting an obscene sexual performance by a child, if convicted.

O'Brien was a band instructor for about five years at Kingston High School and was suspended in May 2001 after town of Ulster police began investigating an allegation by a female student at the school that O'Brien initiated sexual contact with her.

In August, after searching O'Brien's personal computer, police charged the teacher with possessing a sexual performance by a child and two counts of possessing an obscene sexual performances by a child, both felonies, and two counts of endangering the welfare of a child, a misdemeanor. Town of Ulster Police Chief Paul Watzka said police found 31,000 photographs in the computer, many of which depicted girls, believed to be 12-16 years old, in sexual situations. There also were nude photos of O'Brien, Watzka said.

Some of the images had been downloaded from Web sites and others were e-mailed to O'Brien, the chief said.

At the time of O'Brien's arrest, Watzka said the teacher had had sexually inappropriate communication with a 13-year-old girl over the Internet and received several photos of her clothed, partially nude and nude.

O'Brien's lawyer, Daniel Gaffney, said at the time that O'Brien "steadfastly maintains his innocence."

Williams said the charges of endangering the welfare of a child and sexual abuse were the result of testimony by a student, under the age of 17, who said O'Brien initiated sexual phone and e-mail conversations and then sexual contact with her.

The images on O'Brien's computer included sexual acts by and between children, as well as obscene acts by and between adults, Williams said. He would not specify what the photos showed but noted that it is illegal "to possess obscenity that community standards, as set by the grand jury, deem to be patently offensive and serving no legitimate purpose and is and of itself obscene."

There is no evidence that any of the computer images depicted Kingston High School students, but investigators are continuing their effort to identify and locate some of the subjects, Williams said.

In an ironic twist, Williams last year prosecuted the man charged with killing O'Brien's 22-year-old brother, Paul. Paul O'Brien was one of two people who died in February 2001 while riding in a car driven by Jason Stockwell, 21, of Kingston. Stockwell, who police said was driving drunk, crashed into a tree in Palenville; he eventually pleaded guilty to vehicular manslaughter and was sentenced in October to three to nine years in state prison.

Because of Williams' involvement in the Stockwell case, he turned the Todd O'Brien case over to Senior Assistant District Attorney Michael Miranda.

"I feel terrible for the parents of Todd O'Brien because they experienced the loss of their own son," Williams said. "No one said this would be easy, but it is the responsibility of this office to prosecute these acts."

O'Brien has been free on bail since shortly after his arrest.


©Daily Freeman 2010

Reader Comments
 Submit your own comment!
Added: Monday March 18, 2002 at 10:10 PM EST
I can't help but notice the trend for many of those who I've spoken to personally, and indeed, those who have posted on this page, to immedately bias themselves in the negative. Ostensibly, the crimes that Todd O'Brien is charged with /are/ quite wrong. Abuse and/or exploitation of children is one of the most foul and immoral crimes in our society. However, I spent two years with Todd O'Brien, taking his AP classes, and in symphonic band. Whatever his crimes, do not discount the good he has done. I spent time with him daily, and I found him to be an easygoing educator, while still retaining an innate grasp of the material, which is something I cannot claim of many others, even as I approach the end of my bachelor's degree in college. If the legal system finds him guilty, then so be it. He will deserve the punishment. But don't break out the leg irons before the jury has come back in.
Ben
Added: Friday January 04, 2002 at 07:32 PM EST
As one of many students at Kingston High School, we all have our own feelings on the O'Brien incident. We all know him in some way or another. Whether it's through band, musical theatrics, or the recent charges, many students know him or simply know of him. I know Mr. O'Brien very well. This year would have been our fifth year working together. Over the years that I had the privilege of working under his direction in the school setting, I have seen the personality that Mr. Todd O'Brien has brought to school. It is not that of an unsettling individual; it is that of a very professional, caring, responsible adult. As a band director, he was able to reach a new peak with the performance of his band; he was able to instruct Advance Placement Theory students well enough for them obtain 97 and 98 averages; he was able to maintain a program consisting of a symphonic band, lessons, AP Theory, Brass Choir, Auditorium Restoration, and Technical Crew for Theatrics. He managed to do all this in his first 4 years of teaching. When he was not in school, he was busy supporting his St. Joseph Church Schola. With all that Mr. O'Brien did for the school and community, the students here at the high school never had any reason to believe that he would have been anything less than professional. To the students he was never seen as a threat.
Recently, Mr. O'Brien has been charged with counts of Sexual Harassment. Does this make him guilty? Not necessarily. Do accusations make him guilty? I don't think so. Do rumors count for anything? No.
In response to the previous post implying that the students here at the high school do not mind the type of behavior in question, I have answers. The students understand that he has simply been charged. We are, in fact, intelligent enough to know what this means. To charge someone is to accuse someone. Is the accusation correct? Who knows? Is the defendant innocent? No one can answer. The students at Kingston High School who care about the incident do, in fact, have an opinion. They care a great deal, one way or another. Do you want a reason why students are not running screaming to the assistance provided by the high school and why we have remained calm? The reason is very simple. It is intelligence. Those who care about this are intelligent. His supporters believe he is innocent. Enough said. The other end of the spectrum wants to see him in jail. In order for Todd O'Brien to go to jail, he must first have a trial. Do we all remember that little detail? What's the most famous judicial quote? Innocent until proven guilty. So do the students at Kingston High School care about sexual offenders? Of course. Do we already have a standpoint on the O'Brien affair, one way or the other? I believe so. Do we, the students of Kingston High School, need to run to the guidance councilors reporting every teacher who looks at us cross-eyed? No.
Anonymous
View All 6 Comments »

email this storyEmail to a friendpost a commentPost a Commentprinter friendlyPrinter-friendlyTop
Advertisement

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement. Please read our Privacy Policy
©2007 Daily Freeman - a Journal Register Property. All Rights reserved.

Interested in a career with Journal Register Company? Click here.
Journal Register

MidHudsonCentral.com is your local connection to newspaper websites in the Mid-Hudson Region.