Clear 46°5 Day Forecast
News Search

Advanced search
go
NewsClassifiedsYellow PagesShoppingJobsHomesCarsAllAroundCleveland
Home
Jobs
Auto
Real Estate
Today's Deals
Place An Ad
Classifieds
Photo Reprints
Lake Co. Visitors Guide
Mentor Chamber Guide
Willoughby Chamber Guide
News
Top StoriesLocal SportsGraduation 2008Community / AnnouncementsElections 2008ObituariesWeatherOpinions/EditorialsAllAroundClevelandTraffic
Today's Ads
Photo Galleries
Home Delivery
Newspaper In Education (NIE)
Place Classified Ads
Ohio Lottery
Business
Special Sections
Personals
USA Weekend
Fun and Games
Lifestyles
Maps & Directions
Contact Us
Entertainment
Movies
TV
Crosswords
Horoscope
Fun & Games
Site Tools
Yellow Pages
Photo Galleries
7-Day Archive
Services
Subscribe
Photo Reprints
Place An Ad
Browse Today's Ads
Advertising Information
Newspaper in Education
County Kids Rates/Print Dates
Contact Us
News-Herald Jobs
Home : News : News : Elections 2008
Elections 2008
Lawmakers make mess on CCW permit access
09/17/2007
email this storyEmail to a friendpost a commentPost a Commentprinter friendlyPrinter-friendly
State lawmakers - wittingly or unwittingly - started a butcher shop last December. In the heat of the General Assembly's lame-duck session, legislators threw together bits and pieces of a public records bill, with a move to further change access to records for concealed-carry weapons permits.
They served some sausage - the meat where you never know all of the ingredients.
As county sheriff's attempt to digest the legalese, they're left to guess what they should enforce.
Unless lawmakers clean up their mess, the Ohio Supreme Court may be forced in the future to insist elected leaders use far more precision on this critical element of the concealed-carry weapons bill.
Former Gov. Bob Taft insisted the public and media have access to the list of permit holders from county sheriffs before he signed it a few years ago.
That was later amended to strip addresses of permit holders and information about guns, although journalists still could copy the information.
The newest version mollified legislators who have the support of the National Rifle Association and those who think permits should be public records.
It stipulates that citizens and journalists can't physically copy the list of permit holders county sheriffs possess.
County sheriffs are confused by the public records law they're supposed to adhere to beginning Sept. 27. State lawmakers seem perplexed, too.
Consider that Buckeye State Sheriff's Association Executive Director Bob Cornwell said the changes don't make practical sense.
It doesn't allow a reporter to use a tape recorder or to take notes and write the names down.
Consider also that state Sen. David Goodman, R-Columbus, said reporters could not copy names in their notebooks.
Consider that state Rep. Scott Oelslager, R-Canton
and sponsor of the bill, said at the time the law was passed that journalists cannot physically copy the records.
Consider that two of their GOP colleagues said journalists can sit there with a pen and paper and write down the list of all permit holders.
Mark Weaver, a deputy attorney general for Republican Betty Montgomery from 1995 to 1999, said, "It lends itself to tortured interpretation."
State residents suffer the consequences of the poor legislation when they deserve a well-defined measure of accountability for CCW permit holders.
Those who favor the General Assembly's confusion have an ally in Gov. Ted Strickland.
That's why it may require a lawsuit with judges demanding lawmakers clarify public access to concealed-carry weapons permits.
Not serve up some leftover sausage.


©The News-Herald 2009

Reader Comments
 Submit your own comment!
Added: Thursday September 20, 2007 at 08:24 AM EST
Those who have nothing to hide hide nothing.
I not only don't think the law to restrict the media from having a list of CCW permit holders should be amended, I want it abolished. I believe I have the right to know if you are carrying a gun because that knowledge is my only form of protection. If you believe carrying that weapon is a means to defend yourself, then in turn I must have the right to defend myself from you by giving you a wide berth, especially since the rules about who can get a CCW permit are loose enough that you might be the nut who kills me because you've had a bad day the same day I've had a bad day, but you had the killing stick and I only had a bad attitude.
M. Bilyk, Mentor, Ohio
Added: Tuesday September 18, 2007 at 11:21 PM EST
What lawful reason
The only reason that copies of the holders names and addresses are wanted by reporters is to attempt to intimidate them by publishing the lists. The names on that list are of law abiding people that have passed the state mandated steps to carry a weapon, and all the papers want to do is add risk to their lives. In Florida they published the names of license holders and they became the target of crack pots and worse. Policemen and judges home addresses were published so criminals could get revenge, and burglars had a ready made list of targets. Responsible journalism is dead.
S Haynie, Ft Lauderdale, FL
View All 3 Comments »

email this storyEmail to a friendpost a commentPost a Commentprinter friendlyPrinter-friendlyTop

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement. Please read our Privacy Policy
©2007 News-Herald- a Journal Register Property. All Rights reserved.

Interested in a career with Journal Register Company? Click here.
Journal Register
Local Newspapers
News-Herald
News-Herald.com
Morning Journal
MorningJournal.com
AllAroundCleveland.com
AllAroundCleveland.com

AllAroundCleveland.com is your local connection to newspaper websites in Ohio.