Home : Home : Top Stories : Top Stories
Tuesday, December 18, 2007
Home Archives Obituaries Photo Galleries TV Listings Movie Listings Classifieds Place Your Ad Subscribe Contact Us Send News Tips Customer Service About

Yellow Pages

Vernon man gets federal apology for lack of response to terror tip
By Amy Johannes, Journal Inquirer
08/05/2004
email this storyEmail to a friendpost a commentPost a Commentprinter friendlyPrinter-friendly
VERNON -- It's been two weeks since Mike Maney reported suspicious activity near the George Washington Bridge in New York City while driving on Interstate 95 from Vernon to New Jersey last month, and he's finally received a response from law enforcement officials-- an apology.

On Wednesday, the Vernon resident received apologies from the Department of Homeland Security and the FBI in New Haven for not acting on Maney's information sooner.

Maney, 36, had been trying to track the status of the phone call he placed to New York law enforcement authorities on July 22, but until recently came up empty handed. He said he wasn't seeking an apology, just action.

"I appreciate the call," Maney said. "I was never looking for an apology. I just wanted them to take me seriously.

"I just want to make sure this doesn't happen again," he added.

On July 22, on his way from his house in Vernon to New Jersey to buy merchandise for his leather business, Maney saw a man using a handheld camera to videotape the support beams holding the underpass that crosses Manhattan to the George Washington Bridge.

Maney, who was stuck in bumper-to-bumper traffic, says the man with the video camera was traveling with two men, all of whom he believes were of Middle Eastern descent. When the man saw Maney watching him, he put the camera down and rolled up his window, he says.

Every time the vehicle moved ahead, the man popped out the video camera and continued filming, Maney said.

"This was no tourist thing," he recalled.

Alarmed, Maney called 911 from his cell phone and provided dispatchers with a description of the vehicle -- a red Honda Civic DX with tinted windows -- and the vehicle's Florida license plate number.

Maney said he stayed on the phone with police for 20 minutes.

"We thought the bridge would have been shut down," he said. "What I wanted to see was someone pull over the car. But nothing happened."

The suspicious vehicle crossed the bridge into New Jersey before Maney says he lost sight of it. Maney said he even stopped by police barracks in New Jersey to check on his phone call, but was told the call he placed wasn't in the correct jurisdiction.

Coincidentally, Maney's call to New York officials came 10 days before the Department of Homeland Security raised the terror alert because of threats against specific financial institutions in New York City, Washington, D.C., and northern New Jersey.

Maney said he was disappointed with the results, so he called the FBI New Haven bureau a few days later to again report the incident, but was referred to the bureau's New York office and to Homeland Security.

Days passed before Maney heard any response. On Wednesday, Maney had his first contact -- from Detective Patrick Chagnon, a Connecticut state trooper assigned to Homeland Security under the statewide Anti-Terrorism Task Force Unit. The task force is made up of state police detectives and local detectives.

Even though the incident didn't occur in Connecticut, state police spokesman Sgt. J. Paul Vance said, the state Department of Public Safety's division of Homeland Security assigned an investigator to "gather that information to forward to everyone and anyone who it should."

"We investigate any and all issue that are brought to light," Vance said. "We distribute any finds or concerns to the appropriate authorities."

On Wednesday, Chagnon visited with Maney to take a formal statement and write a report. He said he met with Maney to let him and other residents know "there is an outlet available" to report such information.

Residents can always report suspicious activity to the task force's 24-hour tip line, 1-866-457-8477, he said. Phone calls may remain confidential, Chagnon added.

Chagnon said planned to forward the information he gathered from Maney to Capt. John J. Buturla, acting director of the state Department of Public Safety's division of Homeland Security.

He acknowledged there was the miscommunication among the agencies that "needs to be addressed."

"Obviously, communication gaps are abundant in any organization," Chagnon said. "You just have to try to rectify them as quickly as you can."

Also on Wednesday, Maney received an apology from the Department of Homeland Security.

In its statement, spokeswoman Valerie Smith wrote, "At the Department of Homeland Security, we rely on the vigilance of all citizens to be aware of unusual activity and to report it to local law enforcement. We are deeply sorry that, on this occasion, Mr. Maney did not get the immediate response he deserved. We are currently looking into his inquiry and determining how to improve this process."

Connecticut FBI spokeswoman Lisa Bull offered this explanation for a delayed response: "It's common courtesy when someone calls, we try to call them back. It doesn't happen all the time in every instance. Sometime things fall through the cracks, but we try to be professional.

"We take every piece of information seriously, particularly with regard to reported suspicious activity," Bull said.

Maney's experience has also caught the attention of at least one Connecticut congressman.

The office of U.S. Rep. Christopher Shays, R-4th District said today he has been in touch with Maney and he will ask the inspector general's office of the Department of Homeland Security to investigate the issue.

Shays is chairman of the National Security Subcommittee of the Government Reform Committee. The subcommittee is responsible for, among other matters, anti-terrorism efforts

The spokeswoman also said Shays would likely call for a subcommittee hearing based on the inspector general's report. The report is expected to take a broad look at problems associated with calls made regarding reports of suspicious activities.

For Maney, this has been a learning experience. He said if he sees suspicious activity in the future, he won't hesitate to report it, despite his recent experience.

"I will continue to call," Maney said. "This isn't going to deter me."


©Journal Inquirer 2010

Submit your comment now
Comment Title:
Submit your comments on the article in the space below:
Your Name:
Your City & State:  
Your Email Address: (required)
By submitting your comment, you acknowledge that you have read and accept the Terms and Conditions of this site.
Reader Comments
Added: Monday August 09, 2004 at 07:38 AM EST
This just goes to show that the federal goverment is not serious about these so called terrorist alerts. Just another game of politics when the Bushies feel threatened by real democracy.
mary beaulieu
Added: Saturday August 07, 2004 at 06:30 AM EST
It seems an apology was offered by the various agencies after they learned they might be investigated for failure to respond. Is this an opportunity lost to them to question suspicious photographers who might incidentally turn out to be terrorist plotters? Yes. But it also shows that corrective action might be taken in the future that would lead to better intelligence.
Gloria Lemaster
Added: Saturday August 07, 2004 at 12:53 AM EST
I believe that this incident shows us the tremendous lack of security we are suffering under Homeland Security. It demonstrates to me that The Department of Homeland Security needs a new Color Level, Purple.
The Purple Level would indicate: 1. Homeland Security does not have the foggiest notion what they are supposed to be doing. 2. They do not know what they sould do, or who they should contact if we ever do get a warning of suspicious activity. 3. They don't have an inkling of what actions to take if we are attacked, other than call out the National Guard, OOPs, they are all over occupying Iraq and are not available to protect their own country. I suppose we will have to rely on the Boy Scouts and Girl Scouts to protect us instead.
At least we will not have to change the elevation so often any more, as the Purple Level would tell it like it really is.
I only wonder if the George Washington Bridge is ever destroyed by an explosion, if Homeland Security will arrest Mr. Maney as a conspirator because he knows so much about the location of where the explosives were placed?
Let us Pray.......
R. J. MacLachlan
Added: Friday August 06, 2004 at 08:04 PM EST
Nice Job for the CSP and their detective. It's nice to see CT is on the ball. If I'm not mistaken, CT did not have to do anything to try to fix NY lack of service. Keep up the good work CSP!
Todd Kurkland
Added: Friday August 06, 2004 at 03:37 PM EST
I am happy to see that Mr. Maney was willing to step up to the plate and do something. One question though - didn't he get their tag number so that police could track them down? Just a thought.
Delnita Hazell
Added: Friday August 06, 2004 at 02:08 PM EST
AMERICANS HAVE TO WAKE UP AND STOP THINKING THEY WILL CONSIDERED AS BEING SILLY IF THEY THINK SOMETHING ISN'T QUITE RIGHT. IF ONLY SOMEONE ON SEPT. 11, 2001 HAD REPORTED ANYTHING STRANGE. OR HERE IN FLORIDA THE PILOT TRAINING CENTER HAD REPORTED THE PEOPLE WHO ONLY WANTED TO LEARN HOW TO GET UP IN A PLANE AND NOT LAND IT. OUR SECURITY IS UP TO EACH OF US, NOW AND IN THE FUTURE IF WE ARE TO BE SECURE.
BARBARA CHRISTOPOULOS

email this storyEmail to a friendpost a commentPost a Commentprinter friendlyPrinter-friendlyTop
Weather Magnet

News | Sports | Living | Connecticut/Region | Towns | Business | Editorials & Comment | Letters to the Editor | Keith Burris Columns | Chris Powell Columns | Randy Smith Columns | More Sports Columnists | Obituaries | Airtime | Richard Tambling Columns | Tom Wolff Columns | Engagements/Weddings | Connecticut Lottery Numbers | Massachusetts Lottery Numbers Movie Schedules | Connecticut Connections | Town Internet Sites | Jobs at the JI | Classifieds | Photo Galleries | TV Listings | Place Your Ad | Subscribe | Contact Us | About