Clear 32°5 Day Forecast
News Search

Advanced search
go
Home
Shop Now!
Classifieds
Jobs
Auto
Real Estate
Shopping
Place An Ad
News
Regional NewsPolice/CourtsBusinessBlog CentralObituariesWeatherAP - The WireTop Read StoriesMost Talked About
Sports
Life
Opinion
Classifieds
Las Noticias
Photo Galleries
People & Events
About Us
Other Publications
Entertainment
Doorways
Subscriptions
Fun and Games
Consumer Guide
Personal Finance
Lifestyles
USA Weekend
Special Section
Entertainment
Movies
TV
Crosswords
Horoscope
Fun & Games
Site Tools
Yellow Pages
Photo Galleries
Services
Subscribe
Photo Reprints
About Us
Daily Freeman Jobs
Home : News : News : Top Stories
Top Stories
Rochester supervisor faces election challenge
By William J. Kemble, Correspondent
10/18/2007
email this storyEmail to a friendpost a commentPost a Commentprinter friendlyPrinter-friendly

ACCORD - The race for town of Rochester supervisor pits incumbent Democrat Pam Duke, who points to zoning law changes as progress, against Republican Carl Chipman, who objects to the methods used to make changes.

Duke, 64, of 175 Boice Mill Road, Kerhonkson, is a 15-year resident of the town and seeking a third two-year term as supervisor. She has two adult children; is a 1962 graduate of the Lincoln School for girls in Providence, R.I.; earned an associate's degree in liberal arts in 1964 from Green Mountain College in Poultney, Vt.; and earned a bachelor's degree in commercial art from Northern Arizona University in Flagstaff, Ariz., in 1974.

Duke is a retired management consultant with the Girl Scouts and continues to work with the organization. She also a lifetime member of the Parent-Teacher Association.

"The biggest thing right now is we adopted the (town) comprehensive plan in 2006, and now we are developing the zoning laws, subdivision laws and the zoning maps to support the comprehensive plan," she said.

"In 1969, they did a comprehensive plan in this town and no one used it," Duke said. "I do not want to see this get put back on the shelf and collect dust. We definitely need to continue with that because it lays the groundwork for direction for the town."

Duke said there will be priorities that come out of the comprehensive plan.

"In the plan ... we have short-term, mid-term and long-term goals," she said. "So my priorities will be those short-term goals, which will be to address the housing issues in town."

Duke said work also needs to continue on developing an inventory of natural resources.

"We have a grant that we just received, and we're going to continue with that," she said. "With historic preservation, we have received a grant to do some work with that, to update our inventory because we have the largest inventory in Ulster County of historic homes."

Duke also said work is nearing completion to update the town's emergency management plan.

"We had an emergency management plan but it wasn't utilized," she said.

Also, Duke said, "we have a public hearing coming up for putting cell towers in the town. One of the biggest things that hit me when I first became supervisor was I didn't have any Internet access. How can I connect? So now, with the cell towers coming in, we're going to be able to have not only good cell service but we'll also have Internet access."

Chipman, 47, of 15 Barry Lane, is a 42-year resident of the town. He and wife Margaret have two teenage children.

Chipman is a general manger of Collier Motor Car Co. in Ellenville; graduated in 1978 from Rondout Valley High School and earned an associate's degree in economics from Ulster County Community College in 1981. He was a Rondout Valley Board of Education member form 1995-99 and its president during the final two years. He is a coach with the Rochester Youth Commission basketball program.

"I really want to work toward zoning codes that are not infringing on individual property rights of our residents," Chipman said.

"I think we need balanced commercial development," he said. "We have to balance commercial development with ... residential development in order to keep taxes low in our town."

Chipman also said there have been consistent violations in Rochester of the state Open Meetings Law, including a Town Board session where an overflow crowd was locked out of the Town Hall when capacity was reached.

"When in doubt, I will be calling the (state) Committee on Open Government to follow the guidelines," he said.

"They (Town Board members) do a lot of talking in executive session," Chipman said. "I've never seen a government use executive session like these guys do."

Chipman also would like to change the town budget process to accommodate more public comment.

"One thing that I am proposing is that we have a budget review committee ... (with) regular citizens where budgeting is open," he said. "In January 2006, the current supervisor found $60,000 in the budget for a consultant for the comprehensive plan. I don't want to see any money being found, because when you find something, it means you lost it or you tucked it away."


©Daily Freeman 2009

Reader Comments
 Submit your own comment!
Added: Friday October 19, 2007 at 11:03 AM EST
Duke's record makes us cringe
I find it unfortunate that the article on the race made no mention of the controversy in which Supervisor Duke has embroiled our Town. Almost every major official act of the Supervisor's seems designed to divide the Town into two classes: those whose personal desires and political agendas are advanced by the Duke Regime and those whose rights are not only violated but such violations are enshrined in Town Law.

Some examples:

Jon Dogar-Marinesco was denied a place on a Town Committee after a Town Board member publicly stated that - as Republican Club webmaster - he should not be allowed to participate.

Marinesco's wife Manuela Mihailescu was denied a place on a Town Committee after anonymous allegations were made that she runs a porn site. No proof was ever presented to the public or to the Court when she sued the Town. The Court ruled in her favor.

Townspeople - upset over the Mihailescu incident - jammed the Town Hall for the February 2007 meeting. Roughly 100 people (some elderly, some disabled) were forced to stand out in the bitter winter cold. One Councilman made a motion to move the meeting to a larger venue. Supervisor Duke's allies on the Board refused to do so.

During the meeting, one Town Board member told the public that "Public comment is not a right. It is a privilege granted at the sufferance of the Town Board."

When I was recognized during public comment, I was told by the Town Attorney that my remarks on the Town's handling of the Mihailescu situation were on a topic that was forbidden and that I would not be permitted to continue. Following a very short exchange between myself and the attorney on Robert's Rules of Order, the Town Board adjourned the meeting without doing any business whatsoever.

The next Town Board Meeting was a Special Meeting at which no Public Comment was permitted.

Subsequent Public Hearings have been jammed with Townspeople, the vast majority of whom have been highly critical of Supervisor Duke's actions vis-a-vis our civil rights. In particular, by better than a 2-1 margin, the Townspeople have been very vocal in their opposition to the new Zoning Code (as well as the Comprehensive Plan and other precursors and related laws), which seems to be designed to fulfill the interests and desires of a small group of elitists who stand behind the Supervisor.

Supervisor Duke convinced the Town Board to grant her a major pay hike, saying that the job was now a full time job and deserved a greater salary. No mention of such a pay hike was made during her last run for re-election. The Townspeople were not consulted. Perhaps the job is not really a full time job. Rather, it may be that Supervisor Duke requires full time hours to perform the tasks previous Supervisors performed on a part time basis. That, in itself, calls into question whether the Supervisor is fit to continue in her job.

Supervisor Duke was permitted to seek the Republican nomination in 2005. Her Party was invited to have their candidates interview and seek the Conservative nomination this year. Yet, she finds it acceptable that her own Party's rank and file was denied the opportunity to present alternative candidates, including her Republican challenger, at the 2007 Democratic Caucus. In response to these circumstances, half of all Democrats present at the Caucus walked out in disgust. Many of those who remained later expressed their opposition to the lack of openness.

Supervisor Duke's record speaks for itself. All signs point to the fact that her record will come to an end shortly. The voters in Rochester will speak and send her packing.
Imre Beke, Jr., Kerhonkson, NY

email this storyEmail to a friendpost a commentPost a Commentprinter friendlyPrinter-friendlyTop
Advertisement

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement. Please read our Privacy Policy
©2007 Daily Freeman - a Journal Register Property. All Rights reserved.

Interested in a career with Journal Register Company? Click here.
Journal Register

MidHudsonCentral.com is your local connection to newspaper websites in the Mid-Hudson Region.